Shopping Your Business Insurance with AI? Why Sending Your Information to Every Agent May Backfire

Shopping Your Business Insurance with AI? Why Sending Your Information to Every Agent May Backfire

If you’re shopping for business insurance, there’s something important you should know before sending your information to multiple agencies: doing so can actually limit the insurance companies available to quote your business.

AI tools have made it easier than ever to put together a detailed summary of your business, your current insurance coverage and what you’re looking for, then email that information to dozens of insurance agencies at once. It seems like a smart, efficient way to shop around, but there’s a catch that most business owners aren’t aware of.

In commercial insurance, the first agent to submit your business to an insurance carrier may secure access to that market, preventing other agents from obtaining quotes from the same company.

We’re bringing this up because we’ve seen an unprecedented increase in these types of requests at Ricci Insurance Group. We understand the intention. Business owners want to be thorough, compare their options and get the best value for their insurance dollars. Unfortunately, many don’t realize how the commercial insurance quoting process works or that this approach can work against them.

How Insurance Markets Get Blocked

Commercial insurance often involves a process called market blocking.

When an independent insurance agent submits your business to an insurance carrier for a quote, that carrier may recognize the agent as the first to submit the account and decline to accept submissions from other agents for the same business.

For example, let’s say you send your insurance information to eight different agencies. The first agency submits your account to five insurance companies. When the other agents approach those same carriers, they may be told the account is already being worked on by another agency.

The first agent to submit your account isn’t necessarily the agent you would have chosen to work with, the one who best understands your business or even the one who will ultimately follow through with a proposal.

And you may have no idea any of this is happening.

We’re Seeing This Play Out in Real Time

We’ve had multiple conversations recently with prospective clients who initially reached out through one of these mass quote requests.

After taking the time to learn about their businesses, discuss their exposures and explain how our agency approaches commercial insurance, they’ve been excited about the possibility of working with Ricci.

Then our team gets to work, only to discover that many of the insurance companies we’d like to approach have already received their information from another agent.

In some cases, we’re effectively blocked from pursuing the very options we believe might be a good fit.

Meanwhile, the business owner is fielding calls and emails from multiple agencies, trying to keep track of who is quoting what, and may not even realize which agent has access to which insurance company.

What started as an effort to be organized and thorough has made the process more complicated and potentially limited their options.

A Better Way to Shop Your Business Insurance

Our recommendation is to choose your insurance agency first, then let that agency shop the insurance companies on your behalf.

AI can actually be very helpful in the first part of that process. Use it to organize your business information, understand the types of insurance you may need and research agencies that specialize in businesses like yours.

Then have a conversation with the agencies you’re considering. Ask about their experience with your industry, the insurance companies they represent, how they approach coverage reviews and what kind of service you can expect after the policy is issued.

Once you’ve selected an agency you trust, give them the opportunity to approach the appropriate insurance markets.

And if you want to make sure you’re getting a thorough comparison, ask which insurance companies they approached, which provided quotes and why they’re recommending a particular option.

That’s a perfectly reasonable part of doing your due diligence.

Commercial insurance is rarely as simple as comparing prices. Coverage terms, exclusions, deductibles, carrier appetite and the agent’s understanding of your business all influence whether a proposal is actually a good fit.

At Ricci Insurance Group, we work with Florida business owners across a wide range of industries, including contractors, restaurants, real estate investors and other established businesses. We welcome informed clients who ask questions and want to understand their options.

We just want business owners to know that when it comes to shopping commercial insurance, sending your information to more agents doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll get more options.

Sometimes, it means the opposite.

About the Author

Whitney Ricci is the President and Founder of Ricci Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency serving business owners and busy families since 2014. She writes about business insurance, homeowners insurance, risk management, Florida insurance topics, and emerging issues affecting policyholders.

View Whitney's full profile →

Scroll to Top